2 views
Story of Power with Authority
Command chains, control, and authorization powers in major intelligence and security agencies. Each agency has its own unique structure and reporting requirements, but they generally follow a similar pattern, involving multiple oversight layers, especially for sensitive operations.
1. United States
Command Chain: CIA, NSA, and DIA report to the Director of National Intelligence (DNI), who coordinates intelligence activities. The DNI reports to the President.
Authorization Powers:
The President or National Security Council (NSC) authorizes major covert actions.
Congressional intelligence committees provide oversight.
Oversight: Extensive oversight from Congress (House and Senate Intelligence Committees) and the Inspector General (IG) of each agency.
2. Canada
Command Chain: CSIS and CSE report to the Minister of Public Safety and the Minister of National Defence, respectively.
Authorization Powers:
The Minister authorizes CSIS's operations, while the CSE requires ministerial authorization for foreign operations.
Oversight: The National Security and Intelligence Review Agency (NSIRA) oversees Canadian intelligence agencies.
3. United Kingdom
Command Chain: MI6 and GCHQ report to the Foreign Secretary, while MI5 reports to the Home Secretary.
Authorization Powers:
Certain operations need authorization from ministers, especially for activities involving surveillance or covert action.
The Prime Minister can authorize specific high-level operations.
Oversight: Parliament's Intelligence and Security Committee (ISC) reviews intelligence operations.
4. European Union (Key Countries)
Germany: BND reports to the Federal Chancellery.
Operations must have the Chancellor’s authorization for covert missions.
Oversight by the Parliamentary Control Panel.
France: DGSE reports to the Minister of Armed Forces.
Certain operations require presidential approval, especially involving foreign covert actions.
Italy: AISE reports to the Prime Minister.
The Prime Minister authorizes international intelligence operations.
Oversight: Parliamentary committees...
1. United States
Command Chain: CIA, NSA, and DIA report to the Director of National Intelligence (DNI), who coordinates intelligence activities. The DNI reports to the President.
Authorization Powers:
The President or National Security Council (NSC) authorizes major covert actions.
Congressional intelligence committees provide oversight.
Oversight: Extensive oversight from Congress (House and Senate Intelligence Committees) and the Inspector General (IG) of each agency.
2. Canada
Command Chain: CSIS and CSE report to the Minister of Public Safety and the Minister of National Defence, respectively.
Authorization Powers:
The Minister authorizes CSIS's operations, while the CSE requires ministerial authorization for foreign operations.
Oversight: The National Security and Intelligence Review Agency (NSIRA) oversees Canadian intelligence agencies.
3. United Kingdom
Command Chain: MI6 and GCHQ report to the Foreign Secretary, while MI5 reports to the Home Secretary.
Authorization Powers:
Certain operations need authorization from ministers, especially for activities involving surveillance or covert action.
The Prime Minister can authorize specific high-level operations.
Oversight: Parliament's Intelligence and Security Committee (ISC) reviews intelligence operations.
4. European Union (Key Countries)
Germany: BND reports to the Federal Chancellery.
Operations must have the Chancellor’s authorization for covert missions.
Oversight by the Parliamentary Control Panel.
France: DGSE reports to the Minister of Armed Forces.
Certain operations require presidential approval, especially involving foreign covert actions.
Italy: AISE reports to the Prime Minister.
The Prime Minister authorizes international intelligence operations.
Oversight: Parliamentary committees...
